Plumbiferous Media

Scis­sor Sis­ters, glam rock band from (sur­pris­ingly) New York City, just released its third album late last month. Night Work cer­tainly ben­e­fits from the four years Scis­sor Sis­ters has had to work on it; how­ever, it’s less than incred­i­ble. The album alter­nates between being truly unique and all but run-of-the-mill pop, and, need­less to say, it clearly suf­fers in that sec­ond category.

At its best, Night Work is pop with a twist, albeit a very inter­est­ing, sig­nif­i­cant one. While the open­ing track has that typ­i­cal loud, overly catchy per­cus­sive line, the numer­ous, not quite entirely con­trast­ing sec­tions keep the track quite inter­est­ing, and the chords cre­ated in the vocals are noth­ing short of excel­lent, fully mak­ing up for the absolute lack of an actual melody. The sub­se­quent track focuses on its extremely twangy vocals that some­how man­age to sound per­fectly sung among the sounds approach­ing that of slap-guitar. And that’s not even men­tion­ing the sub­tle but engross­ing mixed rhythms between the vocals and instrumentals.

But some­where between “Whole New Way” and “Fire with Fire,” all cre­ativ­ity sud­denly and inex­plic­a­bly dies in its entirety. “Fire with Fire” is one of the most absolutely generic, typ­i­cal pop tracks we have ever heard, and it is by no means wor­thy of being on Night Work. That said, “Fire with Fire” is the worst of the bunch. There are a num­ber of other tracks that are nowhere near as good as they really should be, but for the most part, Night Work is still quite catchy and equally entertaining.

Front­man Jake Shears’ voice fills much of the vocal space of Night Work, though band­mate and fel­low vocal­ist Ana Matronic’s vocal con­tri­bu­tions to the album help to give the album addi­tional color both in join­ing Shears and on her own tracks (such as “Skin this Cat”) - as if any­thing by Scis­sor Sis­ters was lack­ing in vibrance. Shears cries out each line with the fab­u­lously the­atri­cal sense of char­ac­ter that gives Night Work its intense enthu­si­asm. Matronic intro­duces her own sort of enthu­si­asm - just as strong as Shears’, but with a unique, purring tone.

Scis­sor Sis­ters’ lyrics are as provoca­tive as ever, whether it’s openly - “Sex and Vio­lence” couldn’t be any more so - or (slightly) more sub­tle, as with “Whole New Way.” Regard­less of what the they’re singing about, whim­si­cal or seri­ous, Shears and Matronic always man­age an impres­sive level of excite­ment, help­ing to give the music its elec­tric tone. And only a band like Scis­sor Sis­ters, with exactly that excite­ment and that open­ness, could pull off hooks like “What I really wanna do tonight is toughen you up / The harder you get / The harder I sweat” with­out seem­ing ridiculous.

Night Work is at the same time a con­tin­u­a­tion of the style Scis­sor Sis­ters has devel­oped in their last two albums and a devel­op­ment of that style, com­bin­ing the sounds of the band’s self-titled debut and 2006’s Ta-Dah. As such, Night Work ben­e­fits from a some­what more refined style than either of those albums - though it seems lack­ing in the some of the cre­ativ­ity of those albums, espe­cially the excel­lent Scis­sor Sis­ters. Nev­er­the­less, Night Work is ener­getic, vibrant, and cer­tainly enjoyable.

This post is tagged 70-79, Scissor Sisters